November 9, 2020 โ In January 2016, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) finalized a rule that authorized up to 20 permits for fish farming in the Gulf of Mexicoโs federal waters. For 18 months, no one applied.
โThey didnโt want to run the gauntlet of these permits because it was just so fraught,โ said Neil Sims, a serial aquaculture entrepreneur who ultimately broke the stalemate. He proposed a pilot project dubbed Velella Epsilon, which would produce a total of 20,000 almaco jack, a fish native to the Gulf, in state-of-the-art net pens 45 miles off the coast of Sarasota, Florida. Sims said that his company, Ocean Era, aimed to โblaze a trail, so people can see the process that we go through.โ
So far, that process has resembled more of a battle. Years later, the permitting process is still ongoing, and at each step, a mix of local residents and groups representing environmentalists and wild capture fisheries has mounted fierce oppositionโwith public comments, lawsuits, and, most recently, a โpeopleโs hearingโ on the project taking place on September 30.
โThis is potentially a precedent-setting operation,โ said Marianne Cufone, the executive director of the Recirculating Farms Coalition, which promotes a specific style of land-based aquaculture, and a founding member of the Donโt Cage Our Ocean coalition. In Cufoneโs opinion, it must be stopped.