October 4, 2022 โ Environmental advocates, Alaska Natives and commercial fishermen say they are at once confident and anxious as they wait for the EPA to announce a final ban on mining wastes in Bristol Bay, Alaska โ home to one of the worldโs largest salmon fisheries โ that would effectively kill a gold and copper mine estimated to be worth $350 billion.
The Pebble Mine has endured a decadeslong fight spanning three administrations, all of which have moved to block the mine to protect the fishery. The developers, Canada-based Northern Dynasty Minerals Ltd. and other investors doing business as the Pebble Limited Partnership, are still determined to keep the project alive.
It would be unusual for the EPA to reverse its preliminary decision to ban mining wastes from Bristol Bay under a provision of the Clean Water Act, but the Pebble Limited Partnership wonโt be reluctant to take the EPA to court to secure the permits it needs, according to a spokesman.
Meanwhile, Delores Larson, who lives in the Native Village of Koliganek, Alaska, on the Nushagak River, says the possibility of the Pebble Mine getting a green light is terrifying. There are no grocery stores where she lives, she said, no lettuce, bananas or any other imported foods. But there are native berries, moose and other wildlife, including the salmon that begin their northern journey to spawn about 125 miles downstream in the Bristol Bay fishery.
Her people are โsalmon people,โ she said in an interview in Washington last month as she scrolled through pictures of bright pink catch drying in a shed back home in Koliganek and the dark, glossy fillets of her famous salmon jerky. โSalmon is gold to us.โ
Larson had traveled over 3,000 miles to pressure the EPA to finalize its โproposed determinationโ announced in May to โprohibit and restrict the use of certain waters in the Bristol Bay watershed (South Fork Koktuli River, North Fork Koktuli River, and Upper Talarik Creek watersheds) as disposal sites for the discharge of dredged or fill material associated with mining the Pebble Deposit.โ The agency says the project would threaten the bayโs salmon fishery, which this year produced more than 76 million sockeyes, an all-time record harvest.
โHonestly, we would cease to exist as a people,โ she said with a sigh, considering what would happen if the Pebble Mine was built. โItโs our whole life. We depend entirely on our salmon.โ
But developers arenโt keen on letting the EPA strike down a multibillion-dollar project that would tap into what geologists say is one of the worldโs largest reserves of gold, copper and other minerals. They hold that their plan to contain the wastes is sound, despite what the EPA has said in various reports.
โThe record EPA has tried to create for this action is baseless,โ said Mike Heatwole, vice president of public affairs for the partnership. โNo matter the outcome, we will continue to press our case for this important mineral project.โ
A final decision had been expected this month after the EPA received a flood of public comments mostly supporting the plan for banning waste. But the agency announced on Sept. 6 that it would postpone the final determination until December so it could fully review all the comments โ though it hasnโt escaped notice that it means there will be no announcement before the midterm elections.
And the inevitable legal battle ahead would prolong an already lengthy fight for the project.